Today's discussion is important. It is also, fortunately, pretty straightforward.
Can my employer mandate a vaccine?
Can they fire me for not getting a vaccine?
What if I don't think the vaccine is safe?
Doesn't matter. You are entitled to your opinion, but not your job. Your employer is entitled to make a reasonable determination of what it deems necessary to make the workplace safe.
What if I have a religious objection to the vaccine?
Doesn't matter. The Hardison standard makes it difficult to get a religious accommodation (as we have written about before) and although the Supreme Court will probably overturn Hardison soon, even that won't save you here because there is a
direct threat posed by COVID, as discussed below. Also, your
religious objection is probably not
bona fide under the law.
What if I have a medical condition that makes the vaccine unsafe for me?
Doesn't matter. First, you probably will have difficulty getting a doctor who will provide a concrete and well-supported professional opinion that the vaccine is unsafe for you in particular.
Even if you could - even if the vaccine really is unsafe for you and you can prove it - you probably can still get fired right now because COVID-19 is a
direct threat. The employer is not required to give you an exemption if it causes a threat of harm to yourself or others. I think unvaccinated COVID exposure - right now - easily meets that test. If, in order to do your work, you have to go to a place where there are other people - an office, school, hospital, store, construction site, etc - and you cannot do the work from home, there is a direct threat unless you get vaccinated.
Employers are not required to expose their employees, their business, and the public to an unvaccinated coworker just because the coworker wants some special protection.
Is this absolutely iron-clad and legally certain?
No. This is a still-evolving area, and this analysis could be wrong. But I think the courts will be overwhelmingly hostile to vaccine exemptions. Judges have had to remain abreast of the developments because they are employers and public administrators too. Somebody may be willing to take these cases, but all I can say is good luck with that!
My boss thinks he knows it all,
He's a certified S.O.B
No matter how hard I try
He never lets up on me
A dose of his own medicine
Sure would serve him well
When I walk in tomorrow morning
And tell him he can go to hell . . .
Good luck with that
As a matter of fact
I've been down that road before
And I ain't going back
Don't get mad
I just had to speak my mind
Don't waste your time
Or forget your hat
Good luck with that
Pursuant to MRPC 7.4(a)(2)
FREE BACKGROUND INFORMATION AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST
This site is for general information only, and creates no attorney-client relationship. Sending inquiries to the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.
To get legal advice about an employment law, labor law, federal employee law, whistleblower protection, labor unions, worker cooperatives, immigration, discrimination, harassment, wrongful termination, severance, or any related question, you must first have a conflicts check by the firm. We represent exclusively workers, worker cooperatives and unions, but we still must check for potential conflicts of interest, for example, between a supervisor and employee.
First provide the firm with your name, and the name of the person you are making claims against - and no other information. This allows the firm to check for such conflicts of interest. Until you receive confirmation from an attorney that there is NO CONFLICT, none of the information you provide will be considered confidential. Do NOT provide any confidential information before we have asked you to do so.
Once we have confirmed there is no conflict, you may discuss your matter with the attorney in a little more detail, and, if requested, make an appointment. If at your appointment the firm accepts you as a client in writing, then the attorney will be able to provide you with employment law advice.